A Circleville Tradition: Inside the Story of Goodwin’s Family Restaurant

For more than 45 years, Goodwin’s Family Restaurant has been a gathering place for locals, visitors, and generations of families in Circleville. As one of the few remaining classic family restaurants in Pickaway County, Goodwin’s continues to offer the warmth, comfort, and consistency that make small-town dining so special.

Whether you’re craving all-day breakfast, a homestyle dinner, or a hot cup of coffee, Goodwin’s is a go-to stop for anyone exploring Circleville.

A Local Favorite Since 1979

Goodwin’s first opened in 1979 under founder Art Goodwin. Lori Pontious — now the owner — was there on opening day. She worked as a waitress in the early years, moved away for a short time, and returned in 1986 to step into a management role. In 2019, she officially took ownership of the restaurant.

Owning the business wasn’t something she planned for, but it became an easy “yes” when she considered the staff, the customers, and the legacy of Goodwin’s.

“People who’d been here for years didn’t know what would happen if I didn’t do it,” Lori shared. “I’m not sad that I did — it all turned out good.”

Her steady leadership carried Goodwin’s through major challenges, including navigating pandemic shutdowns and transitioning to takeout service until indoor dining resumed.

What to Expect When You Visit Goodwin’s

Goodwin’s is known for familiar comfort food, quick service, and a welcoming, community-focused atmosphere. Generations of families return again and again, often choosing the same dishes they grew up enjoying.

Customer Favorites

• All-day breakfast, especially the well-loved Western omelet

• Country fried steak with gravy

• Hand-breaded chicken tenders

• Roasted and fried chicken dinners

• Homemade desserts, including their signature cream puffs

The restaurant employs around 25–30 staff members, making it an important contributor to local jobs and the broader tourism economy in Pickaway County.

A Community Gathering Place

Goodwin’s draws a wide mix of customers — long-time regulars, large family groups on weekends, and visitors looking for authentic local dining in Circleville. Many guests have been coming for decades, bringing their children and grandchildren to carry on the tradition.

One detail that speaks to the steady flow of guests: Goodwin’s brews an impressive amount of coffee each week (almost 1800 cups per week!). Their team is constantly on the move pouring refills for guests who enjoy settling in for conversation and a warm meal.

Lori says the reason people return again and again is simple:

“People want the experience. They know what they’re going to get. We’re consistent.”

Fresh Updates, Familiar Feel

While the restaurant remains rooted in tradition, it continues to evolve. Goodwin’s has refreshed its interior with new paint, and new booths are arriving at the start of the year, giving the space an updated feel without losing its classic character.

How to Visit Goodwin’s

Goodwin’s offers dine-in service, carryout, and a convenient pickup window behind the building.

Hours

• Tuesday–Sunday: 7:00 AM–8:00 PM

• Monday: Closed

• Breakfast served all day

Goodwin’s does not partner with delivery services — most customers prefer the friendly, familiar in-person experience that has defined the restaurant for more than 40 years.

Explore More Local Dining in Pickaway County

Goodwin’s is one of many beloved eateries that make Circleville and Pickaway County a welcoming destination. From family restaurants to cozy cafés and seasonal favorites, there’s always something delicious to discover.

Plan your visit and explore more dining options at Pickaway.com.