Dining in Pickaway County

In addition to numerous national chains, Pickaway County is home to locally-owned restaurants that offer unique dining experiences. From steak to pizza and everything in between, visitors are sure to find something they enjoy.


Bamboo House Restaurant
1234 N. Court St.
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-7333

Baseball’s Dairy Diamond/Triple Play Pizza
78 Cromley St.
Ashville, OH
(740) 983-4487

Buckeye Station Pizza
11970 Cincinnati Zanesville Rd
Stoutsville, OH 43154
(740) 420-0300

Cardo’s Pizza
505 Lancaster Pike
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 420-3145

Cherry Street Diner
29 Cherry St.
Ashville, OH 43130
(740) 983-9669

Cristy’s Pizza
1029 S. Court St
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 420-9191

Crosstown Creamery and Diner
90 W Main Street
Tarlton, OH 43156
(740) 477-1000

D J’s Pizza & Subs
30 S. Harrison Street
Tarlton, OH 43156
(740) 474-7422

Doughboyz Pizza
15 Front St.
Orient, OH 43146
(614) 877-1100

El Palomar
1412 Circleville Plaza Drive
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-1176

Gant’s Pizza & Pub
114 South Court Street
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-6076

Gibbys Eatery & Sports Bar
126 West Main St.
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 477-3471

Goodwin’s Family Restaurant
214 Lancaster Pike
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-1238

Grand Buffet
1450 Circleville Plaza Dr
Circleville OH 43113
(740) 477-8882

Jackie Ray’s Grill
20 Cromley St.
Ashville, OH 43103
(740) 983-0020

Main Street Pub and Grill
207 W Main St.
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-9078

Manchester Hill Winery
13160 Tarlton Rd,
Circleville, OH 43113
(845) 893-8724

Marcy Store and Diner
1004 Winchester So Rd. (St Rt 674)
Canal Winchester, OH 43110
(614) 837-0734

Mikes Pizza
15 Wright Street
Ashville, OH 43103
(740) 983-2352

Nana & Pap’s Pizzeria & Ice Cream
4 E. Scioto Street
Commerical Point, Ohio 43116
(614) 877-9500

Pizza Cottage
23401 US Hwy 23 South
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-3620

Rafter’s Restaurant at Deer Creek Resort
22300 State Park Rd #20
Mount Sterling, OH 43143
(740) 869-2020

Richie’s New York Corner Deli
206 S. Court St.
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 497- 4663

Scioto Valley Coffee
216 W. Main St.
Circleville, OH
(740) 474-6400

Shifty’s Tavern
122 S. Washington St.
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 420-9835

Station House 81
11 Front Street
Commerical Point, OH 43116
(614) 877-0000

The Goody Nooke
2512 US Rt 22 W
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-9988

Thirsty Parrot Bar & Grill
706 S. Washington St.
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-4201

Tootle’s
119 E. Main St.
Cirlceville, OH 43113
(740) 497-4804

Watt Street Tavern
115 Watt St.
Circleville, OH 43113
(740) 474-2158